How to Decide: Search Firm, Network, or Job Posting for Your Next Hire
By Mike LaRoque
The hire you get wrong is the one you pay for twice. Filling a spot on your golf staff, from a seasonal intern to the head professional who runs your shop, is one of the most consequential decisions you make all year, and most operations still make it out of habit. This article is the anchor of a six-part series on hiring for your golf operation. Over the next five pieces, we will put a real number on what a missed hire costs you, then go role by role through the intern, the assistant, and the head professional, and finish with an honest look at what a search firm actually does.
There are three ways to fill a golf staff opening. Post the job, work your network, or hire a search firm. The usual mistake is picking one out of habit, the same way you always have, without asking whether it fits the role in front of you.
So instead of arguing for one answer, here is a way to reach your own conclusion. Three questions to ask about the role, and then how those answers point you to a method for each position.
The three questions
Where do the best candidates for this role actually spend their time?
Start by being honest about who you’re trying to reach, because that answer decides everything about how you run the search. There are two different pools, and they don’t overlap much. The active pool is anyone updating a resume, refreshing a profile, or scanning job boards on a Sunday night. A good posting reaches them; that’s what a posting is for. But the active pool isn’t the best pool. The candidates that are excellent are usually the ones who are already placed, already valued, and not thinking about a move at all. They’re not reading your posting because they have no reason to look. Reaching them is a fundamentally different act: it’s an introduction from someone they trust, a call from a firm that already knows them, a warm path in through a mutual connection. A posting is a net you set and wait; sourcing the passive market is a series of doors you have to go knock on, one at a time.
So the question is: for this specific seat, is the person I want likely to be looking or likely to be found? If it’s the former, a strong posting and some patience may be enough. If it’s the latter, no amount of posting will surface them, and you either work your own network hard or bring in someone whose network already reaches where yours doesn’t.
What does a mis-hire cost me?
The right amount of process is not fixed; it scales to what’s at stake, so start by pricing the downside. A weak intern is a contained mistake. You lose a season, you learn something, and you move on. A weak head golf professional is a different order of problem entirely. Get it wrong, and you don’t just lose their salary; you get member frustration that compounds quietly, staff who lose confidence, a reputation that takes months to repair, and eventually a second search to undo the first, which may cost you the fee again, the vacancy again, and the credibility of whoever made the original call. The stakes aren’t only financial; they’re relational and reputational, and those are the slowest to recover. So the higher the cost of getting it wrong, the more reach and rigor you want standing behind the decision: a deeper field, more screening, more people weighing in. Not because the process is virtuous for its own sake, but because it’s the cheapest insurance you’ll ever buy against the far higher cost of doing it twice.
How many hours can I honestly give this?
A real search is not a weekend or a two week project. Done properly, a single engagement can touch hundreds of hours before you’re ever presented to a top-tier candidate, and most of that work is invisible.
Sourcing alone means building a real map of the market: not just the people actively looking, but the ones who are happy where they are and would only move for the right seat. That’s list-building, cross-referencing, working your network, and running down referrals that lead to three more calls each. Screening is the part that eats evenings, real conversations, not resume skims: understanding what someone actually wants, whether the comp and the culture line up, will the spouse and kids be happy, whether they’ll still be interested in six weeks, and whether they’ll survive a committee interview. Then there’s coordination, which never shows up in anyone’s estimate: scheduling around busy people, prepping candidates before interviews and debriefing them after, managing the client’s expectations, keeping the back-of-the-pack warm in case your top two fall through, and staying on top of it all so nothing goes quiet at the wrong moment.
If you have those hours to give (genuinely, not in theory) you can run it yourself and do it well. But be honest about your calendar and other responsibilities, not your ambition. If the hours aren’t there, something gets shortchanged, and it’s usually the part you can’t see from the outside: the passive candidates you never reached, the screening call you rushed, the follow-up that came a week too late. The search still closes. It just closes on a smaller, weaker field than it should have, and you rarely find out what you missed.
The Intern/Outside Services
Best candidates: actively looking, easy to reach. Cost of a miss: low. Time required: low.
Every answer points the same way. Post it, and lean on your network for referrals. The pool is students and early-career people you can reach through PGM programs, PGA sections, and the job boards, and warm referrals from other pros cost you nothing. A search firm is almost never the right tool here, because the fee does not match the stakes and you already have the channels you need. However, the one exception is: do you or your staff have the time to dedicate to the process?
The (Senior, Lead, First) Assistant Golf Professional, Buyer/Merchandiser
Best candidates: a genuine mix. Many are actively looking, but the strongest are often already working and doing well. Cost of a miss: moderate. Time required: moderate to high.
This is the role where the framework does the most work, because the answer really does depend on your situation.
Start with your network. For an assistant, a few calls to head pros and DOGs you respect will surface strong names quickly, and those come pre-vouched. Add a posting to widen the pool, especially if your network comes up thin. Then apply the third question honestly. If the role is specialized, the location is a hard sell, or you cannot give the search proper time and dedication, that is when a firm starts to make sense, because a firm reaches past your network into the passive market and does the legwork you do not have time for.
The Head Golf Professional (w/ DOG)
Best candidates: mostly passive. The strongest head-pro candidates are employed, respected, and not applying to anything. Cost of a miss: high. Time required: very high.
Run this role through the three questions, and the answers push in one direction, but the point is that you can see why rather than take my word for it.
On the first question, a posting mostly reaches available people, and available is not the same as the best. It can also broadcast a leadership change you would rather keep quiet. On the second, this is a leadership hire. The head pro helps run the golf shop, leads the staff, owns the member experience, and has to fit both the club’s culture and the DOG’s working style, so the cost of getting it wrong is as high as it gets on your staff. On the third, a proper head search is a heavy, 60+ day process & hundreds of hours landing on top of your day-to-day responsibilities.
Where that leaves you: always use your network, because relationships matter most at this level. But recognize what a purely network-run search cannot easily do. Reach passive candidates discreetly, evaluate everyone on a consistent standard, and limits your risk, and run a defensible process for you and your committee without eating away at the hours you do not have. That is the specific gap a search firm fills, and it is why the investment tends to look small next to the cost of a second search.
Conclusion
So the real answer is not a method, it is a question. How hard is this role to fill, and what does getting it wrong cost you? Answer that honestly and the right path usually names itself, from a simple posting for the intern to a full search for the head pro. The clubs that hire well are not the ones with the biggest budgets, they are the ones that match the method to the moment.
If you have a role coming up and want to talk it through, I am always glad to help.


